Ruut Veenhoven
Published in : DeJong, M.J. & Zijderveld, A.C. (eds) 'The gift of society' Enzo Press
1977 Nijkerk, The Netherlands, ISBN 90-74670-08-3, pp 149-170
ABSTRACT
In the process of modernization, western societies became more individualistic. Ever since
there have been claims that this development will create an unlivable society. Humans
would need a Gemeinschaft and would wither in Gesellschaft. This classic idea lives in
present day 'communitarism' and inspires pleas for the strengthening of moral bonds and
preserving the welfare state.
This paper reports an empirical test of the claim that quality-of-life
is poor in individualized society. It compares 43 nations in the early 1990's.
Individualization is measured by three aspects: 1) moral appreciation of individualism, 2)
opportunity to choose, and 3) capability to choose. Next overall individualization is
measured by means of an expert-estimate. Quality-of-life in nations is measured by the
citizen's subjective appreciation of life as assessed in representative surveys.
The data show a clear positive relationship, the more individualized
the nation, the more citizens enjoy their life. This suggests that the benefits of
individualization are greater than its costs.
Inspection of the scattergrams shows a linear relationship. There is no
pattern of diminishing returns. This indicates that individualization has not yet passed
its optimum.
The relationship appears to be contingent to level of education and
economic prosperity. Positive correlations appear only among the most knowledgeable and
prosperous nations. This suggests that the misgivings about individualization apply more
to the past than to the future.